Website review by Amy Lauren Botula, Common Sense Education | Updated May 2020

LitPick

YA review site gives students a real-world, although ad-driven, outlet

Learning rating
Editorial review by Common Sense Education
Community rating
Based on 4 reviews
Privacy rating
Not yet rated Expert evaluation by Common Sense
Grades
4–12
Subjects & Skills
English Language Arts, Communication & Collaboration, Creativity

Take a look inside

6 images

Pros: Makes students' writing feel relevant, and can validate their effort.

Cons: Sidebar features ads. The design needs updating. Publishers can pay for reviews and promotion.

Bottom Line: LitPick is a decent place for YA lovers to discover and discuss books, but the site is in need of a refresh and features a lot of promotion/ads.

Teachers can use this site to make reading and writing more relevant to their students. No matter the grade, LitPick could be a great fit for an independent reading activity. Students can sign up as reviewers, request books that interest them to review, and then publish reviews as the culminating assessment. Teachers can act as students' sponsors, which allows them to provide feedback and ultimately publish students' reviews. LitPick also supports a book group experience. In this model, an entire classroom can join LitPick as one group, and teachers can monitor the group from a dashboard. Students can all read and review the same book, or choose different ones. There's also an option to do video reviews, which might be good for older students as a way to extend learning beyond the written review.

Teachers should make sure that if students are selecting books to review that the books be age-appropriate. It might be useful to browse with them, or have students complete an initial assignment where they pitch a book they'd like to review.

Continue reading Show less

LitPick is a book discovery and review website with a focus on YA and contemporary literature. What makes LitPick different from other similar sites is that young people contribute the reviews. Students or a group of students sign up with an adult sponsor (an educator, librarian, or family member) and can then request a book to review. The requested book will be sent to them as a hard copy (for a small fee) in two to three weeks, or as an e-book that's instantly downloaded. After reading and deciding how they feel about the book, students can write a review using LitPick's online form, and must do so in four to six weeks. They'll be asked to enter the review, some keywords that other kids can use to search, and a content rating that will help define the appropriate audience; then they'll need to wait for feedback. This feedback can come from a sponsor, or, if there's no sponsor, the review will be screened by a LitPick staff member. After the review has been revised based on this feedback (or if there was no revision needed), the review gets posted by the sponsor or LitPick staff member. After the review is posted, reviewers can request another book and keep writing.

By publishing their reviews, students will feel important and recognized. They'll also have an authentic context to practice writing. Of course, they'll also enjoy picking and getting books to read. Writing the review helps kids process what they've read, and they'll learn a lot as they formulate opinions. Students must learn and practice the language of criticism; they'll explore how to talk about what they like and don't like, and why. To do so, they'll need to think critically while reading and, hopefully, take notes too! That said, teachers will find themselves relying heavily on their existing curriculum. Aside from some review samples and the published reviews themselves, LitPick provides a very basic graphic organizer for review drafting and a lean Educator's Guide best for newer teachers. These resources are fine, but won't totally meet teachers' needs. 

Book choices are limited to those on the LitPick list. While many of these are offered for promotional purposes from publishers and authors (in fact, publishers can pay LitPick for consideration), there's a good selection of books, including some popular titles. There's one missed opportunity for communication, though: There's no place to comment on individual reviews, or to even follow specific reviewers to get book recommendations. Beyond that, the site's design feels, at times, cluttered, confusing, and ad-riddled. This is especially true on the book pages, where kids' reviews are curiously buried below the fold.

Overall Rating

Engagement

Reviews are fun to read, and kids who already enjoy YA literature will like browsing through them and want to participate. The design is aging, features ads, and strangely buries the reviews.

Pedagogy

If kids write reviews, they'll read for pleasure while thinking critically. A review published online is a great motivator -- and a solid assessment opportunity. 

Support

The Educator's Guide and supporting resources are lean but useful. Students can use published reviews and the site's review samples as models for their writing. 


Common Sense reviewer

Community Rating

(See all 4 reviews) (4 reviews) Write a review
Featured review by
Crystal E. , Classroom teacher
Classroom teacher
Centennial Public School
Utica, United States
Excellent Option for Student Book Choice and Reviews!
I love the option of LitPick as a way to have students discover books that they wouldn't have normally read. The delivery time between books allowed my students to then read a more popular book or series in between. Also, the review process was great as a teacher and allowed me to give informal feedback to my students about writing and grammar.
Read full review

Privacy Rating

This tool has not yet been rated by our privacy team. Learn more about our privacy ratings