Review by Jenny Bristol, Common Sense Education | Updated October 2017

Excavate!: Rome

Clever archaeology sim uses object-based inquiry but gets repetitive

Subjects & skills
Skills
  • Critical Thinking

Subjects
  • English Language Arts
  • Social Studies
Grades This grade range is a recommendation by Common Sense Education and not the developer/publisher.
4-8
Common Sense says (See details)
Teachers say (2 Reviews)

Take a look inside

6 images

Pros: In-depth detail about ancient Rome's daily life paired with good discovery-based play and useful review.

Cons: Dig site gameplay gets repetitive, and the excavation techniques could use better instruction.

Bottom Line: While it looks a little old-fashioned, this game offers a good value if you're looking to supplement a unit on ancient Rome with some information on archaeology and daily Roman life.

Excavate!: Rome can fit right into your existing unit on ancient Rome. The game's detailed support documents and lesson plans cover every aspect of the game, including prep for presenting the subject material and game to the class. There's Artifact-Based Questions (ABQs) and Essential Questions for what students will learn, aligned to the C3 Framework. It also has an answer key to the questions asked throughout the game. If you have questions, the publisher's Education Team is available to help with curriculum integration. It'll work well prior to a unit to create a base of knowledge of the time period, or it can be worked into individual lessons in bits and pieces. It'd also function well as an end-of-unit method to review concepts the students have learned.

Students can play solo or in small groups. After working through all the dig sites, students will likely be intrigued by something they discovered in the game, so they could research and present their findings. There's also a Noun Game that offers students a handy review of the game's artifacts and facts about daily life.

Continue reading Show less

Excavate!: Rome is one of a series of (eventually) six archaeology games that each focus on a different civilization. The game is available on the web or as an iOS app. The Excavate! series aims to teach students how to think like archaeologists. In Excavate!: Rome, players join an archaeologist excavation team in Rome to uncover the civilization of the 1st century CE. They are taught proper scientific procedure for excavation, reporting their findings back to the team. Students choose from four sites -- Insula, Domus, Colosseum, and Baths -- but no matter where they begin, they're first taken through a short tutorial dig that covers excavations and the key tools.

After the tutorial, students head to their chosen dig site. Beginning with the first stratum and working down through three or four layers, students must carefully dig using one or more of the excavation tools. Once they hit an artifact with a large tool, they're encouraged to change to a smaller one to avoid breaking the artifact. If they break it, they must begin that stratum again. There are also ceramic potsherds to uncover. Though there are a variety of excavation tools, they aren't listed in order from "big" to "small," and it's not always clear which tool students should be using. It's possible to excavate the whole dig site with just one or two tools, so a more descriptive tutorial would be helpful.

Once each stratum is uncovered, players learn to analyze each artifact by answering questions about it using a ruler and a magnifying glass for closer study. Finally, students complete a report to send back to the team. Most of the words in the report are filled in, with blanks available for drag-and-drop-style completion from a word bank.

In addition to the dig sites, there's a journal for each excavation site for students to revisit artifacts they've uncovered, read longer descriptions, and review the reports. There's also an Archaeology Field Guide, which has fun facts about archaeology and a glossary. The Missions tab shows student progress, and each dig site has a Flashback area that shows the context of where artifacts were found along with further historical facts. While new, the game's visuals fall behind what students might expect. Also, since it's pretty text heavy, struggling readers or ELLs may need assistance.

Continue reading Show less

Archaeology is just flat-out fascinating to kids, and it's a great way for them to experience object-based learning. Ancient Rome also provides an ideal location. Excavate!: Rome will certainly drive student inquiry into the period as they work through the activities and answer the questions presented in the game. Situating gameplay within a unit that offers greater content will round out the experience, however.

Since the game includes authentic artifacts from the period, students don't just learn archaeological procedures and tools, but will also see and seek to understand real artifacts excavated from ancient Roman sites. The game includes historically accurate information about the civilization and way of life of ancient Romans, and gets students delving deeply into an objects' cultural context. History and facts are spread around within the game, and students will need to peruse all areas of the game to gain the most from it.

When used along with the support materials, each game area begins with an overarching question to get students thinking before they go to the dig site. Once in the game, they'll excavate, analyze objects, answer questions, fill out reports, and review what they've learned. The hands-on excavations keep students involved, though the same lengthy method of excavation of each site and stratum may get tedious.

Continue reading Show less
Overall Rating

Engagement Is the product stimulating, entertaining, and engrossing? Will kids want to return?

A lot of terms and rules are presented at the outset; once students get into the action, uncovering interesting artifacts keeps them on the hunt. Graphics are a little outdated.

Pedagogy Is learning content seamlessly baked-in, and do kids build conceptual understanding? Is the product adaptable and empowering? Will skills transfer?

Students learn about both archaeology and ancient Rome. The variety of artifacts and their histories keep students learning through a process of discovery, critical thinking, summary, and review.

Support Does the product take into account learners of varying abilities, skill levels, and learning styles? Does it address both struggling and advanced students?

Students can review how to use excavation tools and the objects they've found at earlier digs, but most of the game help is in the teacher support documents, so students may need guidance if stuck.


Common Sense Reviewer
Jenny Bristol Homeschooling parent

Teacher Reviews

(See all 2 reviews) (2 reviews) Write a review
Featured review by
Susie H. , Classroom teacher
Classroom teacher
Excellent interactive exploration for deeper understanding of Roman civilization

Terrific as a tool to make written/textbook content come to life. I would suggest demonstrating to the class first so that they understand the way the journal works. Not best as an initial learning tool because some knowledge of the Roman civilization/housing is assumed.

Read full review