Teacher Review for Room4Debate

Forum for an electronic debate/Socratic seminar

Sara J.
Classroom teacher
Fort Bend ISD
Sugar Land, United States
Show More
My Subjects English Language Arts
My Rating
Learning Scores
Engagement
Pedagogy
Support
My Students Liked It Yes
My Students Learned Yes
I Would Recommend It Yes
Setup Time Less than 5 minutes
Great for Creation
Further application
Homework
Individual
Knowledge gain
Small group
Student-driven work
Great with Advanced learners
How I Use It
The website is perfect for high schoolers, especially AP juniors, to participate in or analyze argumentative writing. Someone posses a debatable issue (often times accompanied by a position statement, position paper with citations, or additional leading questions) and registered users can participate in or create discussions or debates. In debates, you take a clear stand for or against with all the cons grouped together on one side and all the pros on the other, while discussions do not require the participant to take a stance. This can be used in many ways within a classroom: - Analyze the arguments - Students participate in the debate - Start a debate or discussion
My Take
What is so great about this forum is that it is a perfect model of people sounding smart while debating. The internet is filled with ridiculous and/or poorly written arguments. This really shows the proper way to disagree in a professional/academic/civilized manner. The only issues I see is that an e-mail is required if you want to participate and that at the time of writing this review there is not a large community. I think it is also a perfect place for people to publish opinion essays who are open to feedback on the topic.