Review by Polly Conway, Common Sense Education | Updated August 2012

Creating Music

Cute games teach musical vocabulary, but design needs an update

Common Sense says
Teachers say (4 Reviews)
$avg_user_learning_rating
Write a review
Grades
K-5 This grade range is a recommendation by Common Sense Education and not the developer/publisher.
See subjects & skills

Take a look inside

4 images

Pros: Sweet background drawings create a warm atmosphere for learning and experimenting with musical elements; games are simple but challenging enough for young musicians.

Cons: Some of the design is woefully dated and detracts from the quality of activities available.

Bottom Line: There's definitely enough here to keep kids musically engaged, and with a few tweaks, this website could really shine.

You can use this site as a nice warm-up for any music class or as a treat after a successful practice session. It definitely gets kids in a musical mindset, and young ones will have fun playing around and learning at the same time.

Continue reading Show less

Created by Morton Subotnick, an electronic music pioneer with a long history in music education, Creating Music features a handful of simple games that teach basic concepts like pitch, rhythm, scales, and how different instruments sound. It also offers Musical Sketch Pads, a program where kids can "draw music" on a screen. Using a pencil icon, they'll click on an instrument, then begin drawing. The drawings are then "playable"; kids can hear what their art sounds like.

Continue reading Show less

As for the design, well, some screens look like something your grandpa put together in 1994 and never updated, while others look fine. That is to say, it's not great, and may not impress today's media-savvy kiddos. However, other screens feature lovely hand-drawn backgrounds that are cute and engaging. It's a real mixed bag.

The games are simple and on target musically. Guidance is limited, and while most games are self-explanatory, a little written instruction would be nice. Also, the avatar for the coolest thing on the site, Musical Sketch Pads, says it doesn't work at this time (it's covered with a giant X) -- but we tried it, and it does seem to work on some browsers (though not all). Subotnick transformed Musical Sketch Pads into a pretty fantastic app called Morton Subotnick's Pitch Painter, which might be a better choice if you have access to iPads in the classroom.

Continue reading Show less
Overall Rating
3

Engagement Is the product stimulating, entertaining, and engrossing? Will kids want to return?
3

Kids won't be impressed by the old-school interface; it's just not visually appealing to the modern eye. However, the games are engaging enough to please very young musical beginners.

Pedagogy Is learning content seamlessly baked-in, and do kids build conceptual understanding? Is the product adaptable and empowering? Will skills transfer?
3

With a solid musical basis, these games are reasonably fun and there's some depth of learning going on when kids play around. The musical concepts can transfer to a school band or simply a general understanding of how music works.

Support Does the product take into account learners of varying abilities, skill levels, and learning styles? Does it address both struggling and advanced students?
2

Games are pretty much self-explanatory, but there's a bit of spoken instruction for each. Supports are limited; you can contact the creator by email, but there's no FAQ or specific help section.


Common Sense Reviewer
Polly Conway Classroom teacher

Teacher Reviews

2
(See all 4 reviews) (4 reviews) Write a review
Featured review by
Stephanie E. , Other
Other
3
Decent introduction to basic musical concepts.

This is a decent site for teaching basic musical concepts. I liked to use it for demonstrating and explaining some basic concepts like rhythm, pitch, and tempo. It is very limited though. In order for it to be more engaging it needs to provide more opportunities for students to create and experiment with their own music. Also the graphics are pretty "old school".

Read full review