App review by Jenny Bristol, Common Sense Education | Updated December 2013

Prisoner of Echo

Name: Prisoner of Echo
Item: Prisoner of Echo
Rating: 2
Author: Jenny Bristol

Sound science game doesn't resonate

Learning rating

Editorial review by Common Sense Education

Community rating

Not yet reviewed Write a review

Privacy rating

Not yet rated Expert evaluation by Common Sense

Grades

5–8 This grade range is based on learning appropriateness and doesn't take into account privacy. It's determined by Common Sense Education, not the product's publisher.

Subjects & Skills

Science, Communication & Collaboration, Critical Thinking

Take a look inside

5 images

The built-in dictionary is the best resource in the game.

Students learn factoids sporadically throughout game play.

Students use recorded audio files to unlock doors.

Overly busy graphics impede navigation, and present nearly illegible warnings.

As students move around, they produce sound, which may alert the robots.

Pros: Exposes students to a wide array of sound-related concepts.

Cons: Not much is explored in depth or put into sufficient context.

Bottom Line: Few games deal with sound science, so it's unfortunate that Prisoner of Echo doesn't do it better, ineffectively weaving physics with game mechanics.

How Can I Teach with This Tool?

Prisoner of Echo is perhaps used best as a hook to get students into sound, and as a foundation from which to launch in lessons on sound physics. Even if it doesn't teach the concepts all that well, enough happens in the game that teachers should be able to use the game's mechanics as a touchstone when introducing key terms. Teachers may even ask students to do some reading, or listen to a lecture, and then try to map what they've learned to what they experienced in-game.

What Is It?

Prisoner of Echo is meant to teach students the properties of sound by making sound physics into puzzle mechanics. Students must navigate factories, warehouses, and mining tunnels in an attempt to explore and later escape from the asteroid. Players must learn to manipulate how much sound they're producing because enemy robots who might foil the player's plans are scattered around and listening. But since different areas of the game have different ranges for how far sound travels, there ends up being more trial and error than is desirable.

Is It Good for Learning?

Unfortunately, the learning content feels a bit superficial. What players are actually doing doesn't model sound all that well; rather, sound science serves more as a thematic overlay. There's little explanation of how/why things work the way they do. The built-in dictionary is very descriptive, but without effective context or in-game instruction, students are left with more questions than they begin with. If framed appropriately, however, Prisoner of Echo can get students thinking about environmental ethics since the story deals with preserving or harvesting resources.

Learning Rating

Overall Rating

Engagement Would it motivate students and hold their interest? Is it visually appealing? Would it inspire teachers to try something new or change their instruction?

Giving the kids the power to see and manipulate sound is empowering -- in theory. But inconsistency means fun is traded for frustration, and the graphics make basic navigation and play difficult.

Pedagogy Does the tool help teachers promote a more student-centered experience? Will students gain conceptual understanding or think critically? Does it deepen teachers’ pedagogical thinking?

Information is thrown at players, but is mostly irrelevant to gameplay, lacking context or the ability to apply the information in any meaningful way. The dictionary tool is very thorough, but just as out of context as the built-in learning.

Support Can students and teachers get assistance when they need it? Is it created with people of different abilities and backgrounds in mind? Is learning reinforced and extended beyond the digital experience?

Sparse instructions and a lack of basic help tools. There are no scores, hints, or tips. There are no extensions, and it's only moderately accessible to kids with special needs.

Common Sense reviewer

Jenny Bristol Other

See how we rate and review

Community Rating

No one has reviewed this tool yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Add your rating

This tool has not yet been rated by our privacy team. Learn more about our privacy ratings