Common Sense Review
Updated May 2016

Size Wise - NYSCI

Photo-measuring tool could help with ratios, but not accurate enough
Common Sense Rating 3
Teacher Rating
Not Yet Rated
  • Add calipers to images taken with the iPad's camera to measure displayed image size, input actual object measurements, and show ratios.
  • A nice tutorial is available to help students get started right away.
  • Students can add virtual props from a nice library of ridiculous objects to create fun forced-perspective images.
  • Tool tips are always available to help students navigate the interface.
  • The distance calculations are incorrect every time; the ruler here is actually 156 inches away from the camera.
Great concept for teaching ratio and proportion, fun virtual props to keep kids playing, tons of data, and awesome real-world estimation practice.
Inaccurate distance calculation, lacks some useful features, and props can only be added to live photos (not previously taken shots).
Bottom Line
Lots of potential but not quite there yet; use this to introduce concepts, but rely on more accurate tools for real-world problem-solving.
Galen McQuillen
Common Sense Reviewer
Common Sense Rating 3
Engagement Is the product stimulating, entertaining, and engrossing? Will kids want to return? 3

Adding ridiculous virtual props to photos is always fun. The measurement tools are interesting but won't keep kids focused on mathematical relationships without some kind of outside assignment. 

Pedagogy Is learning content seamlessly baked-in, and do kids build conceptual understanding? Is the product adaptable and empowering? Will skills transfer? 3

Using perspective and indirect measurement is a nice way to work on ratio and proportion, but the interface is a bit confusing and gets in the way of learning that might be better done in person. Inaccurate calculations are a problem.

Support Does the product take into account learners of varying abilities, skill levels, and learning styles? Does it address both struggling and advanced students? 4

Nice tool tips and tutorials help students learn the app quickly or get help when they're stuck. NYCSI's website has a bunch of great curriculum materials and ideas for making the best use of the app.

About our ratings and privacy evaluation.
How Can Teachers Use It?

It's pretty tough for students to grasp ratio and proportion on their own with Size Wise, so using it as a tool for extended discovery learning isn't a great idea. Coupled with good curriculum, it can offer more options for real-world proportionality exercises than old tape measure and shadows lessons, but it still needs to be somewhat teacher-directed. It could be great to start a lesson letting students play around with the app and transition to making measurements by hand on printed photos and doing calculations the old-fashioned way. 

And of course, for pure creative fun, it can't hurt to let kids add props to their images during downtime or even let them make their own forced-perspective shots as an assignment, along with the relevant math. If you're looking for concrete ideas, a great starting place for lesson ideas would be NYSCI's own site, which offers a handful of well-made lessons and tips from real teachers.

Read More Read Less
What's It Like?

Size Wise is a tool that allows students to add virtual calipers to real-world photographs, then use known measurements of those objects to determine distances between them (using ratios). The screen displays ratios of the sizes of objects measured with the calipers, along with the user-submitted actual measurements, enabling proportional calculation of distance. The app will then show its own distance calculations. 

Students can also add virtual props to give their images some goofy flair or use the displayed data to make props appear much larger or much smaller than they actually are. NYSCI's website also includes PDF files of Stick Pics, which can be printed out and held in front of the camera; Size Wise will automatically provide measurement information for them. For reflection and assessment, students can create comic strips using their images and add mathematical expressions displaying the ratios at work. 

Read More Read Less
Is It Good For Learning?

The idea of using image size to object distance is a genuinely great one for making ratios and proportions immediately relevant and accessible to students, so Size Wise is right on the nose for learning. However, in testing, we found the distance calculator to be wildly inaccurate (off by anywhere from 10 to 60 inches), which limits its usefulness a bit. Still, to do these calculations by hand, students will need to have an accurate measurement of image size, and it does seem to correctly display that data. 

It would be nice to include a feature where students could enter an object's distance and have the app display its height, which would open up a lot of learning opportunities. Also, the ability to rotate the calipers to measure width (or arbitrary dimensions) would be nice. Lastly, letting students add objects to images after they've been taken would enable more creative play. 

Read More Read Less

See how teachers are using Size Wise - NYSCI