App review by Patricia Monticello Kievlan, Common Sense Education | Updated March 2016

Get it now

Piano Melody Free

Name: Piano Melody Free
Item: Piano Melody Free
Rating: 2
Author: Patricia Monticello Kievlan

Keyboard app offers lots of songs but few instructional opportunities

Get it now

Learning rating

Editorial review by Common Sense Education

Community rating

Based on 4 reviews

Privacy rating

Not yet rated Expert evaluation by Common Sense

Grades

6–12 This grade range is based on learning appropriateness and doesn't take into account privacy. It's determined by Common Sense Education, not the product's publisher.

Subjects & Skills

Arts, Communication & Collaboration, Character & SEL, Critical Thinking

Take a look inside

4 images

Listen to selections from popular songs and test your ability to play them back accurately.

Adjust keyboard size, playback speed, volume, and more.

Choose from a wide range of songs from classical to pop. Unlock more songs by playing accurately.

A dialog box pops up after users play each selection, displaying both the correct notes and the user's selections.

Pros: The range of available songs is impressive, and additional songs are easily unlocked through "good playing."

Cons: Intrusive ads and non-standard musical notation don't lend themselves to insights that will transfer elsewhere.

Bottom Line: A cool -- but limited -- way for kids to learn to play the piano by ear.

How Can I Teach with This Tool?

Have kids play simple melodies on the keyboard to demonstrate rhythms, intervals, and chords. Kids then can use the app to figure out the melody lines of popular songs or to figure out songs on their own.

What Is It?

Piano Melody Free is a keyboard app intended to help anyone learn to play the piano by ear. Students select a song (songs with titles through the letter "C" are included; accurate playing can unlock other songs on the extensive list), hit the play button to listen to the selection, and listen to a series of sounds as the corresponding notes light up on the keyboard. Students then play the same series of notes and hit a check-mark button to get feedback. A dialog box pops up with the result, listing the correct notes (such as "C4," "C4," "G4," "G4," "A4," "A4," and "G4" for "Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star") and the notes the student played. If the series played is correct, the student can proceed to the next portion of the song to learn further notes and phrases.

Individuals can customize their experience to better suit personal ability and pace; they can change the number of notes they hear in each sample, the playback speed, the size of the keys, and the labels on the notes. They can also change which section of the keyboard is visible using a selection tool near the top of the screen. Although few songs require playing multiple notes at once, the keyboard does so capably.

Is It Good for Learning?

Learning to play by ear is a challenging task, requiring careful listening to the instruments in a song to pick out the melody and then -- with an instrument like the piano -- filling out the song with all the harmony and chords that transform a series of notes into a piece of music. The biggest challenge with this app is that it’s not clear that the skills learned will transfer to music-making in the real world. Mastering the skills on offer here is certainly possible, but it feels more like playing a memory game (think the Simon toy from the 1970s) than learning to play the piano. For students who read music, the notation in the dialog boxes could be frustrating; although the series of notes is correct, it gets unwieldy to read and might be better illustrated with common musical notation.

If a student's goal is to learn the melody line of pop music hits, this app will suit them nicely. It may not be a good fit, however, for anything more complex.

Learning Rating

Overall Rating

Engagement Would it motivate students and hold their interest? Is it visually appealing? Would it inspire teachers to try something new or change their instruction?

With a not-so-great visual style and a strange interface full of ads, this isn't an especially inviting app for learning to play the piano.

Pedagogy Does the tool help teachers promote a more student-centered experience? Will students gain conceptual understanding or think critically? Does it deepen teachers’ pedagogical thinking?

An astonishing range of songs and useful features for listening and re-listening make this an interesting approach to learning to play piano by ear.

Support Can students and teachers get assistance when they need it? Is it created with people of different abilities and backgrounds in mind? Is learning reinforced and extended beyond the digital experience?

Provides effective features for adjusting speed, keyboard size, sounds, and more. Play is intuitive and feedback is immediate, if potentially confusing.

Common Sense reviewer

Patricia Monticello Kievlan Foundation/nonprofit member

See how we rate and review

Community Rating

(See all 4 reviews) (4 reviews) Write a review

Featured review by
Kristy (GAE) L. , Media specialist/librarian

Media specialist/librarian

P.S. 200 Benson
Brooklyn, United States

Fun App, but not very educational

Piano Melody Free offers various options to increase difficulty such as displaying note count, name on note, highlighting the note, etc. It does not offer instruction, but rather a means to practice the notes, or watch the song played. While I like the app and will use it, it is not very helpful in my current educational setting.

Read full review

Write a review

This tool has not yet been rated by our privacy team. Learn more about our privacy ratings