Review by Leslie Crenna, Common Sense Education | Updated March 2013

Get it now

Math - Decimals Subtraction

Name: Math - Decimals Subtraction
Item: Math - Decimals Subtraction
Rating: 2
Author: Leslie Crenna

Get it now

Slick subtraction in 3-D space has great tutorials, frustrating games

Subjects & skills

Grades This grade range is based on learning appropriateness and doesn't take into account privacy. It's determined by Common Sense Education, not the product's publisher.

5–6

Common Sense says (See details)

Teachers say (1 Review)

Privacy rating (How we rate)

Not yet rated

Take a look inside

5 images

Pre-test multiple choice question presents four pairs of expressions laid out horizontally.

Intergallatic Baseball Championship game shows expression next to alien and multiple choices (and time bar) next to character. Players score 50 points for every correct answer but alien scores a run for every incorrect answer.

Performance page displays expressions, correct, and incorrect answers with totals at top.

Hungry Monster game displays expression and timer bar near alien and multiple choices hanging from boxes of fish. Once answer is chosen, players must tap on alien to distract it with the fish.

Super Store game shows athletic shoes costing "25.4" and amount paid as "120.6." Players tap on the key pad (smallest digit first) then "Enter" to give the difference, which displays in the "Balance" area.

Pros: Slick, 3-D graphics, fantastic tutorials on the standard decimal subtraction algorithm in three different situations.

Cons: Games are repetitive, tutorials aren't well-integrated into play, and the gender bias is blatant.

Bottom Line: This slick 3-D math app has unique tutorials and cool space theme, but games don't live up to graphics.

How Can I Teach with This Tool?

Kids could play around with the app as a warm-up or for fun, and the video tutorials, hosted by some pretty cool 3D dudes, might be worth showing as an introduction to decimals subtraction.

What Is It?

Math – Decimals Subtraction is an app that teaches kids a handful of decimal subraction techniques. Fifth- and sixth-graders can learn how to subtract decimals in three categories: subtracting whole numbers from decimals, subtracting decimals from whole numbers (trickiest), and subtracting decimals from decimals. Kids can learn to work quickly to beat timers, and to assess their own work through performance pages at the end of games and pre-post tests. 3-D figures talk kids through the steps in the tutorial section with examples in large numbers.

Kids create a username, select a "friend" avatar, and wander around their virtual room where they tap a TV to enter the games. New users take a 10-item pre-test to "get you warmed up for interesting games ahead." In the Intergalactic Baseball Championship game, kids are supposed to select a correct answer in about 18 seconds, which shortens to 10 when "trick ball" is displayed. Hungry Monster requires kids to select a correct answer and then tap on the advancing alien to distract it with a handful of fish. Super Store requires kids to mentally subtract cost from "amount paid," which is entered into a "balance" display. Kids earn bronze, silver, or gold stars at the end of each game, and a performance table lists all the data: expressions, correct answer, and answer given plus totals. User profiles save test data, but performance data is not saved from one game to the next.

Is It Good for Learning?

It's graphically slick with good tutorials that give kids a solid background in decimal subtraction, but its games aren't that engaging. The developers made an effort to create a pedagogically sound educational game, but in the end, the results are disappointing. Functionality feels disjointed, and text is often hard to read. Tutorials -- the app's best feature -- aren't integrated into play, so kids may overlook them. Plus, they don't address the mental math strategies kids need to do the game's multi-digit calculations. If the games had a built-in calculator that kids could access while playing instead of focusing purely on mental math, the experience might be less grueling. Tests are tedious, have confusing instructions, and include skills the games don't address. Feedback on the baseball mini-game is unintuitive, with correct answers resulting in a strike and incorrect answers earning a home run.

But wait, there's more! The female avatar has her hands on classically cocked hips tossing her head back suggestively. And stragely, she and her male counterpart have no role within games, which feature some other boy pitching a baseball at an alien or saving a girl from an alien by lowering a ladder -- a girl who happens to be hunched over and completely inactive. With all the options available, different choices could have been made.

Rating Details

Overall Rating

Engagement Is the product stimulating, entertaining, and engrossing? Will kids want to return?

High-production-value graphics in 3D are visually appealing, and kids will really enjoy customizing their space-themed room within the game. However, the games themselves could be more cohesive and have easier to read text.

Pedagogy Is learning content seamlessly baked-in, and do kids build conceptual understanding? Is the product adaptable and empowering? Will skills transfer?

The audiovisual tutorials do a great job of describing the basic algorithm for subtracting decimals, but kids need more advice on mental math skills to perform well in games. Also, female characters are represented as weak or sexy.

Support Does the product take into account learners of varying abilities, skill levels, and learning styles? Does it address both struggling and advanced students?

Performance page provides great detail on how well kids scored on each game, but some kids may have difficulty with the hard-to-read text and unintuitive game interface.

Common Sense Reviewer

Leslie Crenna

About our ratings and privacy evaluation.

Teacher Reviews

Write a review

Featured review by
Linda W. , Technology coordinator

Technology coordinator

Wareham Middle School
Wareham, United States

If your students struggle with subtracting decimals then this app might be the one for them. Using games, tutorials and the ability to earn trophies students have the opportunity to mastersubtracting decimals.

As a teaching tool this could be very helpful for students that struggle with decimal subtraction. I was not impressed with the customizing features that students could select (changing outfits, etc) as I want students to focus in on the mathematical skills that need to be mastered. My students all became very aware of the fact that it was okay to use paper and pencil and that many operations in math cannot be done mentally. There are just so many ways that you can teach this math concept so engaging ...

Read full review

Write a review

This tool has not yet been rated by our privacy team. Learn more about how we rate