Common Sense Review
Updated May 2014

Emotion Detective

Fun – but pricey – emotion exercises aimed at kids with ASD
Common Sense Rating 3
Teacher Rating
Not Yet Rated
  • At the starting screen, kids can start a new game to set up an account, continue a saved game, or adjust audio settings.
  • A voice-over describes the context of the picture, and kids must choose which animated face represents the character's emotions.
  • Kids take pictures of themselves or others expressing different emotions, then draw on the areas of the face that show the emotions.
  • Kids listen to a conversation and determine how the characters feel at the end; discussion prompts help deepen understanding.
  • The “Where’s Waldo” search task is the only part of the activity that links to the detective narrative, which has nothing to do with identifying emotions.
Engaging variety of activities allow kids to safely explore emotions and social interactions.
The price is high, and the “mystery” narrative is incomplete and entirely disconnected from the emotion activities.
Bottom Line
Effective for exploring emotions, especially for kids who have trouble identifying or expressing emotion, but not as successful as a game; high price tag may deter some.
Mieke VanderBorght
Common Sense Reviewer
Common Sense Rating 3
Engagement Is the product stimulating, entertaining, and engrossing? Will kids want to return? 3

A variety of activities and approaches to learning emotional awareness keeps kids on their toes. The mystery-solving activities provide tasks kids can easily complete successfully, although they don't tie in with rest of the activities.

Pedagogy Is learning content seamlessly baked-in, and do kids build conceptual understanding? Is the product adaptable and empowering? Will skills transfer? 3

Through multiple-choice questions, kids practice identifying emotions based on facial cues, body language, and other contextual information. Kids also use a camera to experiment with creating their own emotionally descriptive facial expressions.

Support Does the product take into account learners of varying abilities, skill levels, and learning styles? Does it address both struggling and advanced students? 3

Not much in-app help is provided, although most activities include some discussion prompts. Kids can save their progress mid-game, and they get a certificate when they “solve” all four mysteries.

About our ratings and privacy evaluation.
How Can Teachers Use It?

Kids should use the app individually, either independently or with a teacher’s help. Each emotion exercise has a few prompts for discussion or extension, which help deepen learning beyond simple responses to multiple-choice questions. Discussion can go beyond the limited prompts provided as teachers and kids explore what emotions are, how to express them, how to read them, and what are appropriate and constructive ways to interact with others. Teachers could also role-play the same or similar scenarios in the classroom to allow kids to practice expressing different emotions and interacting with one another in safe ways. Teachers can set up separate accounts for each kid and print certificates when they complete all four challenges. 

Read More Read Less
What's It Like?

Kids create a detective portfolio with a picture and their name, then choose from four detective scenarios describing crises in the land of Emotiana. A number of emotional awareness exercises follow, including depicting emotions (happy, scared, disgusted, etc.) with real and animated faces, choosing the correct emotion in a multiple-choice format, taking pictures of faces showing different emotions and using the pictures to draw on areas of the face that change with each emotion, listening to a conversation and identifying how a character is feeling, and looking at a picture and using body language and context to choose the appropriate phrase or emotion. Interspersed are “Where’s Waldo” type tasks, in which kids must find a missing item. When kids finish all the emotion exercises and locate all the missing items, they've "solved" the mystery. Kids can save their progress mid-game and create multiple accounts.

Read More Read Less
Is It Good For Learning?

The emotional awareness activities provide a good variety of exercises for learning how to identify and express emotions in different ways and based on different cues (body language, context, conversation and tone of voice, facial expression, and movement of specific facial muscles). The activities provide great practice for kids who have difficulty reading emotions in others, or expressing emotions themselves, although they would be improved by more diversity in actors and situations.

The detective story narrative is underdeveloped and disconnected from everything else. The search activity is a break from the difficult task of identifying emotions, and clearly draws from the theory that kids with ASD tend to be good at picking out details while ignoring background or context. The app would be greatly improved, however, if the detective story were more seamlessly bound to the emotion-identifying activities. Still, the emotion activities are worth looking into, if you can pay the price.

Read More Read Less

See how teachers are using Emotion Detective