App review by Mieke VanderBorght, Common Sense Education | Updated December 2020
Boxcar AR
Get it now

Boxcar AR

Augmented reality adds wow factor to reading, but has missing pieces

Get it now
Learning rating
Community rating
Not yet reviewed Write a review
Privacy rating
Not yet rated Expert evaluation by Common Sense
Grades
2–5
Subjects & Skills
English Language Arts

Take a look inside

5 images

Pros: Cool looking AR animations make the story come alive.

Cons: There's no way to track students' responses. The excitement of finding animations can easily distract from reading.

Bottom Line: It's a compelling twist on traditional reading for teachers looking for an interesting alternative, but it presents some tracking challenges and might lead to less actual reading.

Teachers can use Boxcar AR with the Boxcar Children books to get students -- particularly reluctant readers -- to find some excitement in reading. The 3D animated characters that pop out of the book are bound to amaze. Some of the embedded questions might also get students thinking, but teachers will need to create their own method of recording how students answer. For the few instances of somewhat open-ended questions, the easiest thing to do might be to have students mark the page number or location in the story, write down the question, and then write their answer. This method is more tedious for multiple-choice questions, so teachers may want to collect the questions on their own and use them as a post-reading quiz. Or, have students read the book first, and then go back with the app to find all the animations. Regardless of how teachers do it, they'll definitely want to have some way to make sure that their students are reading, understanding, and thinking critically about the text rather than just playing with the AR features.   

Continue reading Show less

Boxcar AR is an augmented reality (AR) app series that works with hard copy versions of books in The Boxcar Children series. This review tested only the first book in the series. When users point the device's camera at any drawing in the book, the characters pop out of the book to talk and interact with the reader. Most of the animations reference something that's happening at that point in the text. Some offer just a bit of fun, like the siblings' new dog that pops up and barks. Every once in a while, there are semi open-ended questions for readers to ponder, but most are multiple-choice comprehension questions that ask about something specific that's just happened. For these questions, users tap their choice until they get the right answer. Boxcar AR works with The Boxcar Children books printed after 1942. There's a separate Spanish language app. Each book has an individual app that requires a separate download. While the app store indicates that Boxcar AR has in-app purchases, at the time of this review, there didn't appear to be any pay walls.

Boxcar AR brings the classic stories to life, and adds some limited opportunities for engaging students in deeper learning. It's pretty cool to watch the siblings pop out of the pages of your book, and it almost feels like they're talking to you. For that experience alone, Boxcar AR may be enough to get students excited about reading. What the characters have to say is a bit of a mixed bag. Sometimes the characters provide some additional context that may help readers better understand plot points. Sometimes they ask questions that might inspire students to think deeply about an answer, but there's no way to track responses. And most of the questions are not really all that deep, as they're standard multiple-choice reading comprehension questions. When users get the answer wrong, the characters provide some context that might help get the right answer. Sometimes, though, they say to look at a particular page in the book, but that page number isn't always correct depending on which print edition you're using. Here, too, without any way to record answers, it's impossible to track student performance. Another potential issue is that the excitement of the AR could end up being distracting -- so much so that students focus on that rather than on actually reading. For that reason alone, Boxcar AR will require teachers to be active facilitators but also to do some prep and testing to figure out workarounds for assessment.

Overall Rating

Engagement

The wow factor will certainly grab students' attention. But there's nothing to customize the experience or challenge students at different levels.

Pedagogy

Interaction with the characters can help students engage with reading in a new way. Multiple-choice questions check comprehension and get students thinking.

Support

It's easy to use, but there's no progress tracking or reporting. 


Common Sense reviewer
Mieke VanderBorght Researcher

Community Rating

No one has reviewed this tool yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Add your rating

Privacy Rating

This tool has not yet been rated by our privacy team. Learn more about our privacy ratings